Politicians Change in Argentina, But Will the People?
Beyond politics: There's a cultural shift that needs to happen in Argentina if we want to change.
You are reading The Third Angle. The publication is mostly about crypto and economics, my areas of expertise, but could also be about many other things such as geopolitics, science, AI, and health: all areas I love as well.
The Third Angle is run by Juan Aranovich, an economist from Argentina, managing editor of Unchained, and crypto enthusiast.
In Argentina, Javier Milei’s electoral victory marks a significant turning point. Milei’s philosophy, starkly dividing the populace into the industrious "good Argentinians" and the leeching "bad Argentinians," targets the political elite he labels as Argentina's primary affliction. While his diagnosis of the political class resonates with many, the real challenge lies deeper, within the cultural fabric of the nation.
For years, Argentinians have been entangled in a web of social assistance, a system inflated by economic policies that have paradoxically diminished the value of the help provided. This entrenched culture of dependency has not only eroded individual initiative but also solidified a cycle of economic and social stagnation.
The pivot point now is whether these individuals, conditioned to a state-supported existence, can transition to a labor market that values competition and liberal principles. More crucially, the question is whether they have the desire for such a change.
In-Depth Look at Sociological and Historical Examples
In exploring the societal impact of prolonged reliance on state welfare, a critical insight emerges about how this dependency can subtly erode work ethic and self-reliance. The shift from individual initiative to a cycle of dependency poses a challenge to both societal progress and economic self-sufficiency.
Equally important is understanding how societies react to major shifts in economic policies. People often resist such dramatic changes, and this resistance highlights the need for strategic and sensitive approaches to policy implementation.
The Eastern European Experience Post-1990
After the collapse of the Soviet Union, countries like Poland and Hungary embarked on a journey from centrally planned economies to market-driven systems. This transformation was more than economic; it was a complete societal overhaul. In Poland, for instance, the transition involved dismantling state-owned enterprises and grappling with rising unemployment. Yet, over time, this led to the emergence of a more dynamic and resilient economy, marked by innovation and a new work ethic that valued entrepreneurship and personal initiative.
Chile’s Economic Reforms Under Pinochet
Chile's transition in the 1970s and 1980s under Augusto Pinochet is one of the most stark examples of rapid economic liberalization. Despite the controversial and often brutal nature of Pinochet’s regime, the economic reforms implemented during this period transformed Chile’s economy. The privatization of state-owned enterprises and the liberalization of the market led to significant economic growth. However, this transition was not without its societal costs, as it widened economic inequality and left certain segments of the population disenfranchised.
New Zealand’s Economic Shift in the 1980s
New Zealand's economic reforms in the 1980s, initiated by Finance Minister Roger Douglas, were a response to a crippling economic situation. Known as "Rogernomics," these reforms included deregulation, privatization of state assets, and tax reforms. The initial impact was harsh, with rising unemployment and social unrest. However, these reforms eventually stabilized the economy, reduced government deficits, and laid the groundwork for sustainable economic growth. New Zealand's experience illustrates the potential long-term benefits of economic liberalization, albeit with significant short-term societal challenges.
Conclusion
Milei’s ascendancy in Argentina has ignited a sense of optimism, but the journey ahead is complex and multifaceted. The nation’s transformation hinges not just on policy changes but on a deeper cultural shift. Will the Argentinian people embrace a new ethos of self-reliance and innovation? The examples of Eastern Europe, Chile, and New Zealand demonstrate that while such transitions can be arduous and fraught with challenges, they also open pathways to long-term prosperity and societal rejuvenation.
Argentina now stands at a crossroads, facing the challenge of rewriting its cultural narrative from one of dependency to one of empowerment and growth. The road ahead is not just about economic restructuring; it is about reshaping societal values and attitudes toward work, self-sufficiency, and the role of government in everyday life.
Also, read my recent articles on Argentina’s situation: